You reach for the M&Ms bag-and it's empty. No time to run out, and the recipe's half-prepped.
The best swap depends on whether you need that candy shell crunch or just chocolate bits. Pick based on the texture your recipe needs, not just the chocolate flavor.
**Chocolate chips** deliver pure chocolate flavor in baking, while **candy-coated gems** (like Smarties) match both the shell crunch and colorful look. Candy-coated peanuts work for cookies and trail mixes but add a nutty note. Most swaps use a 1:1 ratio by volume, though you'll trade either the candy shell or some visual pop.
6 Top M&Ms Alternatives That Hold Up
These swaps match the chocolate flavor, candy shell texture, or both-depending on what your recipe calls for.
Remember it later
Planning to try this recipe soon? Save it for a quick find later!
| # | Substitute | Best For | Ratio | Key Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Candy-Coated Peanuts | 🍳 Cooking | 1:1 | Adds nutty flavor |
| 2 | Chocolate Chips | 🥧 Baking | 1:1 | No candy shell |
| 3 | Candy-Coated Gems | ✨ Both | 1:1 | Softer shell |
| 4 | Crushed Candy Bars | 🍳 Cooking | Equal volume | Uneven pieces |
| 5 | Vegan Candy Candies | 🌱 Vegan | 1:1 | Slight texture shift |
1 - Candy-Coated Peanuts
These deliver the candy shell crunch and chocolate coating M&Ms are known for, plus a nutty center instead of plain chocolate. They work great in cookies and trail mixes where that extra peanut flavor blends with other ingredients.
Use a 1:1 swap by volume, but expect a stronger nutty background and slightly thicker coating.
Quick specs:
- Milk chocolate and candy shell match the original crunch
- Nutty center changes flavor profile more than plain chocolate
If you're out of candy-coated peanuts too, what to use for peanuts covers nut-free options.
Skip if: You need a nut-free recipe or neutral chocolate flavor.
2 - Chocolate Chips
Chocolate chips give you pure chocolate flavor in a similar-sized piece, but you lose the candy shell crunch and colorful look. They're a solid pick for baked goods like cookies and brownies where the shell isn't doing structural work.
Chocolate Chips
Works for: Baking where candy shell isn't needed
Skip if: You need colorful toppings or candy crunch
M&Ms
Works for: Recipes needing candy shell and multiple colors
Skip if: Shell texture isn't important
Swap 1:1 by volume, but keep in mind chips melt faster without that protective coating. They'll spread more in the oven and blend into dough rather than stay distinct.
Here's what to know:
- Pure chocolate flavor without candy coating sweetness
- Melt faster and spread more during baking
- Only one color-usually brown or dark
Missing chocolate chips as well? chocolate chip replacements has a few more options.
Skip if: The recipe depends on colorful candy pieces for decoration.
3 - Candy-Coated Gems
Candy-coated gems like Smarties match M&Ms nearly perfectly-you get chocolate inside, a crunchy candy shell, and multiple colors. The shell tends to be softer and sometimes has a slight tart note, but the overall effect is close.
Use a 1:1 swap by volume. The shell may melt faster in high-heat baking, so they shine in no-bake treats or as final toppings.
The essentials:
- Sweet, slightly tangy candy shell with milk chocolate center
- Softer shell texture than M&Ms
- Holds up better in cold applications than high heat
Skip if: You're baking at high temps where shells break down.
4 - Crushed Candy Bars
Crushed candy bars with chocolate and nuts give you crunchy chocolate bits mixed with caramel or nut flavors. They're less uniform in shape and size, but they work well as ice cream mix-ins or dessert toppings where texture variety adds interest.
Use an equal volume as a substitute, but chop pieces to roughly match M&M size if uniformity matters. The added flavors-caramel, nougat, nuts-shift the taste more than a straight chocolate swap.
Key details:
- Chocolate plus nutty or caramel notes
- Less uniform shape and size
- Additional nut flavors can clash with some recipes
- Works best as topping rather than baked-in ingredient
Skip if: You need uniform candy pieces or neutral chocolate flavor.
5 - Vegan Candy Candies
Vegan candy-coated chocolate candies mimic M&Ms with a plant-based chocolate center and colored candy shell. The texture and sweetness can vary slightly by brand, but they deliver the same basic crunch and visual pop.
| Use | Ratio | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Baking | 1:1 | Shell may be softer |
| Toppings | 1:1 | Colors hold well |
| Trail mixes | 1:1 | Slight sweetness shift |
Swap 1:1 by volume. The candy shell texture can be slightly different-sometimes thinner or less crunchy-but it's close enough for most recipes.
Quick specs:
- Similar chocolate flavor with plant-based center
- Slightly different candy shell texture depending on brand
Skip if: The recipe demands exact M&M texture and you're sensitive to small differences.
Making M&Ms Substitutes Work
Most of these swaps work at a 1:1 ratio, but the trade-offs vary. Match the function-candy shell crunch, chocolate flavor, or colorful look-to your recipe's needs.
Start with a small test batch if you're swapping in baking. Some alternatives melt faster or add unexpected flavors.
- Closest match - Candy-coated gems for shell and color
- Easiest grab - Chocolate chips for pure chocolate
- Dietary option - Vegan candy candies for plant-based recipes
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, use a 1:1 swap by volume. Chocolate chips melt faster without the candy shell, so they'll spread more and blend into the dough rather than stay as distinct pieces.
They match the candy shell and chocolate coating, but the peanut center adds a nutty flavor. The overall sweetness and crunch are similar, but the taste profile shifts.
Yes, but their softer shell melts faster at high heat. They work better in no-bake treats or as toppings added after baking.
Vegan candy-coated chocolate candies offer the closest match-plant-based chocolate center with a colored candy shell. The texture may vary slightly by brand, but they work at a 1:1 ratio.
Yes, chop them to roughly match M&M size and use an equal volume. Keep in mind crushed candy bars add caramel or nut flavors and less uniform texture.
5 Best Substitutes for M Ms
Ingredients
Method
- Choose your substitute based on recipe needs: for candy shell crunch, chocolate flavor, or colorful appearance.
- If using crushed candy bars, chop pieces to roughly the size of M&Ms for even texture.
- Apply a 1:1 substitution ratio by volume for all substitutes unless noted otherwise.
- Remember chocolate chips melt faster without candy coating, blending more into baked goods.
- Candy-coated gems work best as toppings or in no-bake desserts where shells stay intact.
- Check the final texture and flavor, especially with nutty or vegan alternatives, and adjust if needed.
