Go Back
–+ servings
Substitutes for Shishito Pepper

7 Best Substitutes for Shishito Pepper

No ratings yet
These seven substitutes provide alternatives to shishito peppers, each suited to different cooking methods from blistering to roasting and fresh raw uses. Whether you seek mild heat, tender-crisp texture, or sweetness, these options cover a broad spectrum of flavor profiles and textures.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 12 minutes
Cook Time 8 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Servings: 4 servings
Course: Kitchen Tips, Substitutes
Cuisine: Various
Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients
  

  • 1 cup Padrón Peppers 1:1 ratio, closest flavor and texture
  • 1 cup Banana Peppers 1:1 ratio, best for roasting or grilling, thicker flesh
  • 1 cup Cubanelle Peppers 1:1 ratio, no heat, best in raw dishes
  • 1 cup Anaheim Peppers 1:1 ratio, variable heat, thicker flesh for cooking
  • 1 cup Sweet Mini Peppers 1:1 ratio, no heat, best fresh
  • 0.5 cup Jalapeño Peppers (deseeded) Half volume, remove seeds and membranes to reduce heat
  • DIY Mild Pepper Blend Per shishito: 1 small diced banana pepper + ¼ teaspoon smoked paprika, adds smoky notes

Method
 

  1. Choose your substitute based on cooking method: Padrón for blistering, banana or Anaheim for roasting, cubanelle or sweet mini for raw.
  2. Prepare peppers as needed: deseed jalapeños to reduce heat; slice banana peppers into rings for even roasting.
  3. Apply recommended ratios for each substitute, adjusting volume when indicated.
  4. Check final taste and texture; adjust seasoning or cooking time to replicate shishito’s mild heat and tender-crisp bite.

Notes

  • Padrón peppers provide the closest match for blistered dishes due to similar thin walls and heat profile.
  • Jalapeños require deseeding and reduced quantity to avoid overpowering heat.
  • DIY blends add smoky flavor but lack fresh pepper crunch, best for sauces and seasonings.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!