Go Back
–+ servings
7 Smart White American Cheese Swaps When You're Out

7 Best Substitutes for White American Cheese

No ratings yet
White American cheese is valued for its smooth, creamy melt and mild flavor. These seven substitutes offer options that replicate the texture or provide a sharper or firmer profile depending on your dish's needs such as grilled cheese, burgers, or queso.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 6 minutes
Cook Time 6 minutes
Total Time 12 minutes
Servings: 4 servings
Course: Cheese, Substitutes
Cuisine: American
Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients
  

  • 1 cup Colby Cheese Use equal amounts; melts into a smooth sauce with a slightly firmer texture than American when cold
  • 1 cup Mozzarella Cheese Use equal amounts; stretchy and elastic but less creamy and less salty than American
  • 1 cup Havarti Cheese Use equal amounts; buttery and creamy finish with a softer texture when cold
  • 1 cup Provolone Cheese Use equal amounts; melts smoothly with mild tang and firmer texture
  • 1 cup Monterey Jack Cheese Use equal amounts; smooth, creamy melt slightly firmer than American when cold
  • 0.75 cup White Cheddar Cheese Use three quarters cup for one cup of American; sharper and more intense flavor
  • 1 cup Processed White Cheese Slices Use equal amounts; melts with creamy, smooth processed flavor nearly identical to American

Method
 

  1. Choose your substitute based on the dish: grilled cheese and queso for creamy melts, burgers for texture or tang.
  2. Prepare the substitute as necessary—no special prep needed for these cheeses since they are ready to use.
  3. Apply the substitute using the recommended ratio, typically a 1:1 swap except for white cheddar which uses ¾ cup per cup of American.
  4. Heat gently and watch melt times to avoid differences such as mozzarella becoming rubbery on high heat.
  5. Adjust seasoning or amount slightly as needed to maintain desired flavor and texture balance in the dish.
  6. Taste the dish and check consistency before final serving to ensure the substitution works well.

Notes

Use Monterey Jack slowly and taste-test to prevent a texture that is too oily or a flavor that is too mild.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!