Go Back
–+ servings
Substitutes for Portobello Mushroom in Marinades

7 Best Substitutes for Portobello Mushroom

No ratings yet
If you’re out of portobello mushrooms or want alternatives, these seven substitutes cover different cooking methods and dietary needs. They range from similar mushrooms like cremini and shiitake to vegan options like tofu and eggplant, all aiming to replicate the meaty texture and umami richness of portobello.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 8 minutes
Total Time 18 minutes
Servings: 4 servings
Course: Kitchen Tips, Substitutes
Cuisine: Various
Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients
  

  • 1 cup Cremini Mushrooms Use 1:1 by volume as a nearly identical substitute with milder flavor.
  • 1 cup Shiitake Mushrooms Use 1:1 by volume, remove tough stems before use.
  • 1.25 cup Button Mushrooms Use 1.25 cups button mushrooms per 1 cup portobello for bulk and moisture.
  • 1 cup Eggplant Use 1:1 by volume, peel and cube, salt before cooking to remove moisture and prevent
  • 1 cup Firm Tofu Use 1:1 by volume of pressed tofu, slice thick or crumble,
  • 1 cup King Trumpet Mushrooms Use equal volume; slice thick for grilling or tear lengthwise for a pulled texture.
  • DIY Mushroom Powder + Tofu Blend Mix ½ cup pressed crumbled tofu with 1 tablespoon mushroom powder per 1 cup chopped

Method
 

  1. Choose the best substitute based on your dish and dietary needs.
  2. Prep the substitute: wash, peel, press, or crumble as needed; salt eggplant slices to reduce moisture if used.
  3. Use the recommended substitution ratio and adjust volumes accordingly.
  4. Marinate or season substitutes like tofu or eggplant to add umami depth.
  5. Cook substitutes by grilling, sautéing, or roasting as appropriate for your recipe, and check taste and texture before serving.

Notes

  • Cremini and king trumpet mushrooms maintain meaty texture suitable for grilling or stuffing.
  • Tofu and eggplant absorb marinades well but lack mushroom umami unless enhanced with seasonings.
  • DIY mushroom powder blended with tofu boosts umami and mimics ground mushroom texture for sauces and fillings.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!