Go Back
–+ servings
7 Best Substitutes for Kasseri Cheese for Stretchy Greek-Style Melt

7 Best Substitutes for Kasseri Cheese

No ratings yet
Kasseri cheese can be hard to find and its substitutes vary by dish. Choose provolone for smooth melting, asiago or kefalotyri for sharper flavor, and muenster or Monterey Jack for mild melts.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Servings: 4 servings
Course: Cheese
Cuisine: Greek, Mediterranean
Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients
  

  • 1 cup Provolone cheese shredded, use 1:1 ratio for kasseri
  • 1 cup Asiago cheese grated, use 1:1 ratio for kasseri
  • 1 cup Monterey Jack cheese shredded, use 1:1 ratio for kasseri
  • 1 cup Caciocavallo cheese use equal amounts for kasseri substitute
  • 1 cup Muenster cheese sliced, use 1:1 ratio for kasseri
  • ¾ cup Kefalotyri cheese use ¾ cup for every 1 cup kasseri
  • 1 cup Manchego cheese shredded, use 1:1 ratio for kasseri

Method
 

  1. Provolone melts smooth and stretches similarly to kasseri. It's milder, with less tang and a creamier finish. Use in grilled cheese, saganaki, and baked dishes for gooey pull.
  2. Asiago offers a sharper, nuttier flavor and firmer texture better for grating than melting. Use grated asiago over pasta and baked dishes.
  3. Monterey Jack melts clean with a buttery mild flavor, good for quesadillas and casseroles where cheese should blend into the background.
  4. Caciocavallo has a similar stretched-curd structure with sweeter, more complex flavor and holds up under high heat. Ideal for grilling and frying like saganaki.
  5. Muenster quickly melts to a very soft, smooth consistency with mild buttery flavor. Use in sandwiches and mild casseroles but avoid high-heat cooking.
  6. Kefalotyri is harder, saltier, and sharper. It melts less creamy but works well in saganaki and as a grating cheese over Greek pasta. Reduce added salt when using.
  7. Manchego melts similarly to kasseri with a sweeter, nuttier finish. Firm enough for grating but melts smooth in baked dishes. Good for cheese plates or Spanish/Greek recipes.
  8. Match the cheese substitute to your cooking method: soft melters for saganaki, firm cheeses for grating, and mild cheeses for sandwiches or casseroles.

Notes

Drain provolone before using to prevent watery dishes and ensure a smooth melt.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!