Go Back
–+ servings
7 Best Substitutes for Caciocavallo Cheese for Firm, Savory Melting

7 Best Substitutes for Caciocavallo Cheese

No ratings yet
Caciocavallo cheese is valued for its sharp tang and stretchy melt in dishes like pasta bakes and pizza. These seven substitutes range from mild, smooth melting options to sharper cheeses ideal for grating. Choose based on whether you need a creamy melt or a bold, aged flavor.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Servings: 4 servings
Course: Cheese, Cooking
Cuisine: Italian
Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients
  

  • Provolone Cheese Use equal amounts as caciocavallo; milder, smoother melt
  • Aged Pecorino Romano ¾ cup per 1 cup caciocavallo; sharper and saltier
  • Scamorza Cheese Use equal amounts as caciocavallo; milder, slightly smoky
  • Aged Mozzarella Use equal amounts as caciocavallo; sweeter and less sharp
  • Aged Asiago Cheese Use equal amounts as caciocavallo; nuttier, firmer texture
  • Fontina Cheese Use equal amounts as caciocavallo; buttery, ultra-smooth melt
  • Manchego Cheese Use equal amounts as caciocavallo; nuttier, drier texture

Method
 

  1. Provolone melts smoothly and stays creamy in baked dishes but is milder and less tangy than caciocavallo.
  2. Aged Pecorino Romano delivers a sharper, saltier punch and crumbly texture but lacks stretch.
  3. Scamorza stretches well when heated, with a milder flavor; smoked variety adds smoky notes.
  4. Low-moisture aged mozzarella melts beautifully but is sweeter and milder than caciocavallo.
  5. Aged Asiago is nuttier and firmer with less stretch; grates well over soups and risottos.
  6. Fontina melts ultra-smoothly in fondues and gratins but is buttery and lacks sharp tang.
  7. Manchego is firmer, drier, and nuttier; best used shaved over finished dishes, not for high-heat melting.
  8. Choose provolone or scamorza for melting in pizzas and baked dishes, or aged pecorino and asiago for sharp grating.
  9. Use equal or adjusted ratios as noted for each cheese substitute to maintain flavor balance.

Notes

Drain aged pecorino romano before using to prevent overpowering saltiness in your dish.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!