Go Back
–+ servings
7 Best Substitutes for Broiler Pan for Oven Roasting and Broiling

7 Best Substitutes for Broiler Pan

No ratings yet
Practical substitutes for a broiler pan, ranked by lift, drainage, and heat handling. Use the right swap for the protein size and expected fat level. Follow simple prep and timing adjustments.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 8 minutes
Total Time 18 minutes
Servings: 4 servings
Ingredients Equipment Method Notes

Ingredients
  

  • Roasting Pan Ratio 1:1; closest match for lift and drainage; may not fit under broiler element
  • Baking Sheet Rack Use a rimmed sheet + oven-safe rack (1 sheet + rack); best balance of airflow and cleanup; less drip depth
  • Cast Iron Skillet Ratio 1:1; great for high-heat sear; no drip tray so fat pools and may smoke
  • Grill Pan Ratio 1:1; adds grill marks and lifts food slightly; shallower drainage than a rack
  • Foil Pan Ratio 1:1; thin and single-use—place on a sturdy baking sheet to prevent warping
  • Cooling Rack Use rack over sheet (centered) to elevate food; confirm it's oven-safe and heavy-gauge
  • Glass/Ceramic Dish Ratio 1:1; even heat but no rack; watch heat limits and avoid thermal shock

Equipment

  • Roasting pan with rack Mimics broiler pan's two-tier setup
  • Rimmed baking sheet Used with an oven-safe rack to catch drippings
  • Oven-safe cooling rack Place over a rimmed sheet to elevate food
  • Cast iron skillet Holds high heat for a strong sear
  • Grill pan Ridges lift food and create char lines
  • Disposable foil pan Single-use option; place on a sturdy sheet for support
  • Glass or ceramic baking dish Even heat but no rack; watch temperature limits

Method
 

  1. Choose the substitute by use: roasting pan for large roasts, baking sheet + rack for vegetables and thin steaks, cast iron for an intense sear.
  2. Prepare the tool: center an oven-safe rack on a rimmed sheet and line with foil for easy cleanup, or preheat a cast iron skillet 3–5 minutes.
  3. Measure oven clearance before broiling with a roasting pan; if the pan sits lower than a broiler pan, add 2–3 minutes to the recipe timing.
  4. Manage fat: empty a baking sheet halfway through if grease pools or flip thicker cuts halfway for even browning and reduced smoking.
  5. Support thin pans: place a disposable foil pan on a sturdy baking sheet to prevent buckling and spills under high heat.
  6. Safety and checks: confirm racks are oven-safe, avoid placing foil directly on the oven rack, and check doneness with a thermometer or visual cues.

Notes

Empty a rimmed baking sheet halfway through cooking to prevent pooled fat from smoking.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!